How to critique a qualitative study. Critiquing Qualitative Research 2019-02-25

How to critique a qualitative study Rating: 9,5/10 1615 reviews

Research Critique Qualitative study Essay

how to critique a qualitative study

Methodology: participants Is the population described adequately? In this essay I will base my research within the realms of mental health nursing which is my area of professional practice. It would have been better to have a full description of who conducted them and the duration of each instrument. As stated by Polit and Beck 2010, p. Many ask the question why is it hard to attract and keep nurses at a long term facility. Put simply, we think so. Whilst the conceptual framework for the study is clear, the literature review does not strongly argue for the need for such a study. Therefore, it is essential for nurses to develop the skills necessary to analyze a research article.


Next

Research Critique Qualitative study Essay

how to critique a qualitative study

Basing from the intrinsic limitations of the study, Bernstein lists a number of recommendations to follow up her research among which is the conduct of related studies that either strengthen data collection techniques or broaden the time and setting of the study. Moreover, research in itself contains its own process with a methodological approach. Twelve patients of a detoxification and rehabilitation unit for substance and gambling addictions were recommended by a volunteer informant. This study focuses on how the nurses feel about where they work and what makes them want to leave or stay at a job. The first phase deals with the identification of the problem, review the literature, develop theoretical framework and formulate valuables as stated by Borbasi and Jackson, 2012. The University of Nebraska requires that a qualitative Master's thesis has the following sections: Title, Introduction, Methods, Review of Literature, and the Creative Piece. Paradigm issues in regards to methods for gathering and indeed the ways of treating data are revealed in the introduction.


Next

Qualitative Research Critique Essay

how to critique a qualitative study

Reliability in quantitative research is often thought of as consisting of stability, equivalence and internal consistency Cohen et al. One of the strengths of this study is the reliability concerning trying to understand learner difficulties. The proposed research method, i. This has helped in improving knowledge base on qualitative nursing researches Brookes, 2007. With high turnover there are many disadvantages for the facility as well as the resident and employees. There were four randomizedā€¦ 1465 Words 6 Pages Unit 6: Critiquing Qualitative and Quantitative Research Kaplan University July 16, 2013 Unit 6 Critiquing Qualitative and Quantitative Research The research conducted by Foster-Fitzpatrick, Ortiz, Sibilano, Marcantonio and Braun 1999 is a quantitative study of the significance of crossing the legs while blood pressure is being measured.

Next

Qualitative Research Critique Essay

how to critique a qualitative study

Discussion on psychological research methodology is beyond the abilities of this author and so except for the above-mentioned similarities, the article by Goh is generally considered to be ethnographical research. Is there a clear description of how the instrument was administered? This eliminated the possibility of mono-method bias or a threat to validity where a construct is measured by only one means Trochim 1999. This is consistent throughout the study as the participants include women who have either type 1 or type 2 diabetes, although the title did not specify the pregnancy status of the participants. The reader will examine her use of grounded theory qualitative research method based on the guidelines provided by Geri LoBiondo-Wood and Judith Haber 2014. More reliability issues are discussed below.

Next

Qualitative Research Critique Essay Example for Free

how to critique a qualitative study

This is why you need our highly specialized service as we will provide you with an expert that will be capable of providing you with precisely the help that you require. It is systematic and enabled readers to find information with ease. All work is completely unique and will be written totally from scratch rather than copied as some other services provide. This study focuses on how the nurses feel about where they work and what makes them want to leave or stay at a job. Are interviewers and observers trained? Popular methods vary by field, but include qualitative as well as quantitative approaches. While logically it would appear that in this kind of study this should not affect the results, it would have been more comforting for the reader to have such details. Research questions which seek to describe a phenomenon may be better suited to quantitative methods, such as experiments or surveys.

Next

How to Critique a Quantitative & Qualitative Thesis

how to critique a qualitative study

The pragmatic benefit of the research to practitioners could be said to lie here. Nonetheless, the abstract is able to distinguish the specific purpose identified for the research and how the actual procedures and findings matched the problem. Our samples can provide you with a huge amount of guidance and ideas as to what areas you need to cover within your review and how you should structure and format your critique. Maybe little research exists within the specific area of evaluating listening through a cognitive framework, however more relevant information concerning cognitive processes e. This article will be reviewed based on plausibility, the trustworthiness, and its significant to to future and current nursing theory or practice. Again this poses a problem because we know what the researcher is going to do but the specific questions that need answering are not explicitly written. Nonetheless, the small sample size is acceptable for a pioneering study such as this.

Next

How to Critique a Research Methodology

how to critique a qualitative study

This research report will be analyzed using the criteria found in the Critiquing Criteria box on p. Certainly more citations from other empirical studies would have been more convincing than mere references to certain others ho share the same beliefs. Most basically, research questions which seek to understand a phenomenon may be best answered with qualitative methods such as case studies or narrative approaches. This is except to say the author notes the extensive preceding research that has focussed on other types of factors affecting listener difficulties. If the interviews, diary entries and verbalizations were carried out honestly and authentically then these instruments could be seen as some of the most valid and practical for ascertaining what invisible and cognitive problems are occurring. A quantitative hypothesis should not provide conjecture, but a measurable statement that can be proven with statistical, number-based research methods.

Next

Qualitative Research Critique

how to critique a qualitative study

The researcher claims that redundancy was used as the primary criterion in sample selection which implies that homogeneity was achieved. Unfortunately, many older adults are viewed as if their opinions or ideas are not worth listening to. The tables and charts give an overview of the results and point the reader to the text with an idea of the importance of each listener problem as measured by number of respondents with the attributing problem. Are the conclusions clearly stated and based on the results and the discussion? They will discuss the task directly with you through our online services to ensure that it is clear exactly what you are looking for. Although her study was limited in sample size and one-time interview, her preliminary findings are consistent with the related literature and buttress the use of acupuncture as a treatment to substance abuse.

Next

Essay on Critiquing a Qualitative Nursing Research Article

how to critique a qualitative study

First, even when a specific method answers specific research questions, data disparities and questions that arise during research often cause scientists to redesign their studies. Is there an emphasis on primary resources? Journal of Cardiovascular Nursing, 26 4 , 336-344. The lack of details concerning the administration of the diaries, interviews and verbalization process could be seen as the greatest weakness of this study. However, literature synthesis is not provided. There are many different methods that you can use to conduct qualitative research so at times it can be very difficult to understand exactly what has been done if you are not familiar with the methods that have been used.

Next